Best Pizza in Starkville

Updated October 2026 · 8 places · Starkville

Ask AI

Summarize this page with

ChatGPTClaudePerplexityGoogle AI

Starkville has a small mix of independent pizzerias and other local restaurants that serve pizza, alongside national chains. The list below prioritizes local spots; the last three are chains included to bring the list to eight, rather than nearby or out-of-state businesses.

Editorial illustration: Best Pizza in Starkville

The list

  1. 1

    Boardtown Pizza & Pints

    $$ · 705 University Dr Ste C, Starkville, MS 39759

    Boardtown Pizza & Pints is a locally owned restaurant centered on Neapolitan-inspired pizza. Reviews mention its thin crust and fresh, well-seasoned toppings, with pepperoni and Kitchen Sink among the pizzas diners call out.

    Best for: Neapolitan-style pizza

  2. 2

    Stromboli’s Italian Eatery

    $$ · 408 University Dr, Starkville, MS 39759

    Stromboli’s is a local Italian eatery serving hand-tossed pizza, strombolis, calzones, and pasta. Reviews frequently praise the calzones and describe its pizza crust as sweet and flavorful, though opinions about the pizza’s texture vary.

    Best for: pizza and calzones

  3. 3

    Lost Pizza Co. Starkville

    $$ · 325 Highway 12 W, Starkville, MS 39759

    Lost Pizza Co. is a casual pizza restaurant serving pizza and other Italian-American food. Diners mention its chicken-and-garlic and spinach Alfredo pizzas, as well as calzones and wings.

    Best for: casual pizza meal

  4. 4

    Dave’s Dark Horse Tavern

    $$ · 410 Dr Martin Luther King Jr Dr E, Starkville, MS 39759

    Dave’s Dark Horse Tavern is a neighborhood tavern that serves New York-style pizza. Its own site describes it as Starkville’s oldest pizzeria, and local listings also identify it for thin-crust and deep-dish pizza.

    Best for: pizza and tavern atmosphere

  5. 5

    Bin 612

    $$ · 612 University Dr Ste 3, Starkville, MS 39759

    Bin 612 is a Cotton District restaurant and bar whose menu includes scratch-made pizza alongside burgers and tacos. Local coverage highlights the pizza and its casual setting near Mississippi State University.

    Best for: pizza with a broader pub menu

  6. 6

    Old Venice Pizza Co.

    $$ · 110 E Main St, Starkville, MS 39759

    Best for: downtown pizza

  7. 7

    Pizza Hut

    $$ · 911 Hwy 12 W, Starkville, MS 39759

    Pizza Hut is a national pizza chain with a Starkville location. Its local store page confirms the address and lists it as a currently operating pizzeria.

  8. 8

    Domino’s Pizza

    $$ · 101 Hwy 12, Starkville, MS 39759

    Domino’s is a national pizza chain with a Starkville location. The company’s store page confirms the address and current operating hours.

Your town, every weekday morning

What’s on today, new local guides and stories, in one short free email.

Free. Unsubscribe any time.

Own a business in Starkville? Get listed free in the Starkville business directory.